Thinking is one of the ways we try to make sense of our experiences. We reflect on what has happened, consider different perspectives and attempt to understand ourselves and the people around us. Often, this is helpful. But sometimes thinking can become a way of keeping our emotional experiences at a distance.
We might find ourselves repeatedly analysing a difficult conversation, trying to establish exactly what went wrong or what we should have said differently. We may be able to describe our difficulties with considerable insight, recognising patterns in our behaviour and understanding where they originated. Yet despite this understanding, something remains unresolved.
There can be a difference between understanding an experience and allowing ourselves to feel it.
For some people, thinking offers a sense of control. Feelings such as sadness, anger, shame or vulnerability can be uncomfortable, unpredictable or difficult to tolerate. Analysing them can feel safer than experiencing them directly. We remain engaged with the problem, but at a distance from its emotional significance.
This isn't necessarily a conscious choice. Over time, we may have learned that certain feelings are unwelcome, overwhelming or unlikely to be understood by others. Thinking can become a familiar way of managing that discomfort.
In therapy, this can sometimes emerge as a tendency to explain rather than experience. Someone might speak eloquently about their relationships, their childhood or their difficulties, while remaining relatively disconnected from how these experiences affect them in the present.
The invitation isn't to stop thinking or to regard intellectual understanding as unhelpful. Rather, it is to become curious about what thinking might be doing for us, and whether it sometimes prevents us from encountering something important.
This might involve noticing what happens when we allow a little more space for uncertainty, sadness or vulnerability without immediately trying to resolve it.
Understanding ourselves can be valuable, but insight alone doesn't always bring change. Sometimes a different relationship with our experience begins when we become less concerned with explaining what we feel, and more willing to remain with what is already there.